Kickstart Your Revision With Your Bookclub's Help

One of the best decisions I made about 10 years ago was to join my church book club. As a writer who spends much of her spare time in isolation with her work, I relish the book club meetings. We women gather monthly over potluck meals, glasses of sparkling wine, and desserts that leave us with mild regret. The book selection could be a literary novel, ethnic fiction, a presidential biography, or a bodice ripper bordering on the erotic.

We are a sorority of sorts, women in our 40s, 50s, and beyond catching up on each others' lives and providing each other with emotional and spiritual sustenance, while always preserving time for the discussion of the book.

I have watched these women identify stilted dialogue, uncover the layers of a main character’s motivations, rail against a novel’s ending, and engage in a grueling debate over the necessity of an adverb.

That’s why last fall, when I was completing a draft of my novel in progress, I knew I wanted my book club to read it.

Having your book club select your manuscript for discussion has its benefits.

You know they’ll read your work. I’ve had friends promise to read my manuscript but then never heard from them again. However, book club members are committed to attending the meetings and they hate to show up having not read the book.

You know you’ll get feedback. At my meetings we assign one member to facilitate the discussion, guaranteeing that the conversation will stay on topic and get to the heart of members’ opinions.

You’ll get proofreading and copy editing services for free. You may want to have paid professionals clear your writing of typos, grammatical mistakes, and passages that just don’t work, but it doesn’t hurt to have more than a dozen pairs of eyes flagging anything that seems amiss.

You’ll have an automatic fan base. Your book club friends are your support group. They’ll want you to succeed. They’ll appreciate being brought into the process during the early stages. They’ll be your ambassadors, telling others about your writing and their role in helping you. 

 To get the most out of the experience, I gave my book club friends some guidance. I included a questionnaire with the manuscript copies I handed out to get the kind of feedback I wanted. Also, I assured them that they didn't have to spare my feelings during the discussion, that I wanted them to be as candid as they would be for any other written work. 

My book club friends told me the truth. While they loved my narrative, subplots, and dialogue, they didn’t care for my main character. They didn’t like her. They didn’t feel sympathy for her plight. They also thought her best friend added nothing to the story and wasted the reader’s time.

I’ve since revised the manuscript, keeping in mind their feedback.

Book club input may not get you an agent, but you can get thoughtful, constructive feedback in a supportive environment.

*Photo: Woman reading, 2003 Item 139224, Fleets and Facilities Department Imagebank Collection (Record Series 0207-01), Seattle Municipal Archives. Used under Creative Commons License.

grubstreet Image
About the Author

Lisa Braxton is the recipient of a 2020 Outstanding Literary Award from the National Association of Black Journalists for her debut novel, The Talking Drum, published in May 2020 by Inanna Publications. Her stories and essays have appeared in The Boston Globe, WBUR’s Cognoscenti, Vermont Literary Review, Black Lives Have Always Mattered, Chicken Soup for the Soul and The Book of Hope. She is a fellow of Kimbilio, a fellowship for fiction writers of the African diaspora, and an Emmy-nominated former television journalist. She earned her Bachelor of Arts degree in Mass Media from Hampton University, her Master of Science degree in Journalism from Northwestern University and her Master of Fine Arts degree in creative writing from Southern New Hampshire University and is a former newspaper and television journalist.

See other articles by Lisa Braxton
by Lisa Braxton


Craft Advice

Rate this!

Current rating: 5